1058 Tiller Dr: How My Buyers Won a Millcreek Home Against Multiple Offers

What happened with the sale of 1058 Tiller Dr in Incline Village?

1058 Tiller Dr, a 5-bedroom, 3,212-square-foot Millcreek home on 0.363 acres, remodeled in 2020, sold for $5,000,000 in November 2026 to buyers I represented. It drew three offers, including a backup, and went under contract within days of coming on the market. My buyers won with an offer $5,000 over the $4,995,000 asking price and terms built around what the sellers needed.

This post covers what my buyers were looking for, how a two-year search prepared them to move quickly, and what helped their offer stand out.

1058 Tiller Dr at a Glance

Detail
NeighborhoodMillcreek, Incline Village
PropertyTwo-story single-family home, no HOA
Built1992, remodeled in 2020
Bedrooms5, with 2 on the main level
Bathrooms3.5
Square feet3,212
Lot0.363 acres
Garage2-car
IVGIDFull privileges, including beach access
My roleBuyer's agent
List price$4,995,000
Sale price$5,000,000 (November 2026), about $1,557 per square foot
Offers3, including a backup
Time to contractWithin days of coming on the market

What My Buyers Wanted

My clients had lived in Incline Village for years, in a few different neighborhoods. They owned a single-family home within an HOA and wanted to move up to a larger home outside of one. Millcreek was the neighborhood they’d always had in mind: flat, close to the lake and consistently in demand.

We looked for about two years, across Millcreek, Lakeview Subdivision and The Woods. Many of the homes I showed them were off-market or not yet listed.

1058 Tiller wasn’t one of those. It came on the market publicly. But by the time it did, my buyers had seen a wide range of comparable homes and knew what they wanted. I also knew about a handful of homes preparing to come on the market in the area. That let us compare 1058 Tiller against what was coming, not just what was listed, and confirm it was the right fit. It helped on price too, since we knew what similar homes were likely to sell for.

For more on how I find homes before they’re listed, see how I work with buyers.

Competing Against Multiple Offers

Homes like this one draw competition in Millcreek: a 2020 remodel on a third of an acre, with no HOA and full IVGID beach privileges. 1058 Tiller drew three offers, including a backup. Here’s what helped my buyers’ offer come out on top.

  • A working relationship with the listing agent. I hadn’t worked with the listing agent before. Over our two tours of the home, we spent two to three hours together. Getting to know each other in person built trust and gave me a clear picture of what the sellers needed.
  • Price. My buyers offered $5,000,000, $5,000 over the asking price. On a $5 million home that’s a small amount, but in a close competition it helped push the offer over the line.
  • Terms built for the sellers. The listing noted furnishings were negotiable, and we structured the contract around the sellers’ priorities on furnishings and repairs.
  • A strong first offer. My buyers led with their best offer instead of planning for a counter.

The Result

My buyers went under contract within days of the home coming on the market and closed in November 2026 at $5,000,000. Because the offer started from common ground on terms, the transaction that followed was smooth for both sides, with give and take where it was needed.

What Buyers Can Learn From This Sale

  • Know the market beyond the MLS. Seeing off-market homes and knowing what’s coming soon helps you recognize the right home when it appears, and move with confidence.
  • Do your learning before the home you want comes up. Two years of tours meant my buyers were ready to act within days.
  • Relationships matter in a multiple-offer situation. Time spent with the listing agent built the trust that helped the offer win.
  • Price is one piece. Terms that solve problems for the seller, like furnishings and repairs, can carry as much weight as the number.
  • Lead with your best offer. In a competitive situation, you may not get a second chance.

For more on Millcreek, see my Millcreek neighborhood page and my post on Millcreek’s rebuild potential.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did 1058 Tiller Dr sell for?
$5,000,000 in November 2026, $5,000 over its $4,995,000 asking price, with three offers including a backup.
How do you win a multiple-offer situation in Incline Village?
Offer a strong price, build terms around what the sellers need, and build a working relationship with the listing agent. Knowing the market well enough to act quickly also helps.
Can a buyer's agent help me see homes that aren't on the MLS?
Yes. Many of the homes I showed these buyers over two years were off-market or not yet listed. See how I work with buyers.

Thinking About Buying in Millcreek?

Millcreek homes don’t come up often, and the good ones draw competition. If you’re thinking about buying here, I’m glad to walk you through what’s listed, what’s coming and what it takes to win. Call or text me at (775) 558-9540, or schedule a consultation.

Sale details per Incline Village MLS. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

About the Author: Hayden Haffey is an Incline Village resident and Realtor specializing in the hyper-local submarkets of the Nevada North Shore. With a background in family consultancy, Hayden prioritizes an educational, data-driven approach over high-pressure sales, helping clients navigate the complexities of Lake Tahoe real estate with clarity and intentionality. When he isn’t analyzing market trends, you’ll likely find him skiing, mountain biking, or enjoying the lake with his wife and two daughters.

Hayden Haffey, Global Real Estate Advisor, Sierra Sotheby’s International Realty